Mobile Nav
Check out the new "Daily Free Picks" Link with ALL Nation's Best Cappers
Login or Create a New Account Email Address: Password:
Fill out the following information to sign up for an account and receive our free picks.
(Only your Email Address is Required)
First Name:
Last Name:
Email Address:
Address:
City:
State: Zip:
Enter this code:
Your Selected Article is Below - Return to All Articles

Top NFL Handicappers Ranked: September Betting Leaders and Insights
Sep 30th, 2025

The world of sports betting is as much about finding value as it is about understanding who to follow. Each week, bettors search for the most profitable handicappers to guide them through the grind of NFL, college football, MLB, and beyond. Below, we break down the top 10 NFL handicappers ranked by profit, ROI, win percentage, and betting performance. Whether you’re a casual bettor just starting out or a seasoned sharp looking for edges, this ranking highlights the cappers making waves right now.

  1. Info Cash Picks
  • Profit: $900
  • ROI: +90.2%
  • Win PCT: 100.0% (9-0)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Few runs in sports betting are as rare as perfection, but Info Cash Picks is sitting at 9-0. With an ROI north of 90%, this capper has been an absolute bankroll booster. Even the sharpest bettors recognize how difficult it is to sustain flawless records, but right now, Info Cash Picks is delivering a dream start.

  1. Ray Monohan
  • Profit: $577
  • ROI: +17.0%
  • Win PCT: 61.3% (19-12)
  • Avg. Odds: -110

Known as "Razor Ray," Monohan has long been a reliable name in sports betting circles. With a solid 61% win rate and nearly $600 in profit, he’s proving again why so many bettors lean on his daily card. His consistency across NFL and college football matchups is exactly what disciplined bankroll managers crave.

  1. Timothy Black
  • Profit: $501
  • ROI: +18.1%
  • Win PCT: 62.5% (15-9)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Timothy Black has been quietly efficient, producing a clean 62.5% win rate while keeping ROI close to 20%. Bettors following his selections are seeing consistent returns, proving that patience and disciplined handicapping can turn small edges into reliable profit.

  1. Marc Lyle
  • Profit: $446
  • ROI: +21.2%
  • Win PCT: 63.2% (12-7)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Marc Lyle has stood out by combining one of the highest win rates on the board with a healthy ROI. Winning 63% of his picks while generating over $400 in profit, Lyle shows a knack for identifying mispriced markets. For bettors chasing value, this is a profile worth tracking closely.

  1. Steve Janus
  • Profit: $438
  • ROI: +23.8%
  • Win PCT: 64.7% (11-6)
  • Avg. Odds: -108

Janus has combined sharp pricing with elite win percentage. His 64.7% hit rate stands as one of the best on this list, and the +23.8% ROI shows he’s maximizing every play. A strong start like this often signals a capper who knows how to exploit both spreads and totals effectively.

  1. Bobby Wing
  • Profit: $426
  • ROI: +15.7%
  • Win PCT: 60.0% (15-10)
  • Avg. Odds: -108

With 25 total picks already in the books, Bobby Wing is showing bettors that volume doesn’t mean recklessness. Winning at a 60% clip with +15.7% ROI, he’s carving out a profitable run that leans on consistency. For bettors who prefer frequent action, Wing’s style is appealing.

  1. AAA Sports
  • Profit: $318
  • ROI: +16.0%
  • Win PCT: 61.1% (11-7)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

AAA Sports has long been a household name in betting communities, and this current run is more proof of their value. A 61% win rate paired with a 16% ROI gives bettors confidence in their systems. AAA’s track record across multiple sports makes them a multi-season threat.

  1. Frank Sawyer
  • Profit: $269
  • ROI: +8.1%
  • Win PCT: 56.7% (17-13)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Frank Sawyer is the definition of a grinder. While his ROI sits at a modest +8.1%, his volume ensures bettors still come away in the green. Sawyer’s long-term reputation as a methodical capper makes him a steady option for players who prefer less variance in their betting portfolios.

  1. Matt Fargo
  • Profit: $261
  • ROI: +8.1%
  • Win PCT: 57.1% (16-12)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Another respected voice in the industry, Fargo delivers a classic “slow and steady wins the race” profile. His 57% win rate and +8.1% ROI may not jump off the page, but over time, these results compound for serious profit.

  1. Dave Price
  • Profit: $251
  • ROI: +6.8%
  • Win PCT: 56.2% (18-14)
  • Avg. Odds: -111

Rounding out the top 10 is Dave Price, whose steady numbers place him on the profitable side of the ledger. Price’s balanced card offers bettors the kind of reliability that turns bankroll management into long-term success.

Final Thoughts

The key takeaway from this leaderboard is that different handicappers excel with different approaches. Some, like Info Cash Picks, are riding near-perfect streaks, while others like Steve Janus and Marc Lyle are winning with elite efficiency. Still others, such as Frank Sawyer and Matt Fargo, thrive by staying disciplined and grinding out consistent returns.

For sports bettors—from beginners learning bankroll discipline to veterans seeking ROI optimization—this ranking provides a snapshot of where the smartest money is flowing.

👉 Want more? Visit PicksDepot.com for free picks and premium releases from these cappers and many more. Bet these winners at  MyBookie and shop for lines at OddsLogic

Posted by Mike Godsey (Profile) | Permalink | Comments (0) | Trackbacks (0)
Mike Godsey is the lead NFL handicapper for Godspicks, featured at OffshoreInsiders.com
There are no comments for this article

Post Comment

The Trackback URL for this article is:
http://www.offshoreinsiders.com/index.php?Page=Articles&ArticleID=12686&action=trackback


< October 2025 >
S
M
T
W
T
F
S
   1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031